Issue #21780 has been updated by knu (Akinori MUSHA). The argument that Enumerator.produce is infinite by nature is certainly valid. However, the change that made Enumerator#to_set refuse to operate when the size returns infinity introduced a compatibility issue: it breaks existing code that relies on calling #to_set on Enumerator.produce (that the programmer knows is finite) being possible. Redefining Enumerator::Produce#to_set to ignore the size is one way, but that would be awkward and incorrect in the long term. This decision was made after balancing backward compatibility against what the default size of produce() should be. ---------------------------------------- Bug #21780: Change the default size of Enumerator.produce back to infinity https://bugs.ruby-lang.org/issues/21780#change-115709 * Author: zverok (Victor Shepelev) * Status: Open * Backport: 3.2: UNKNOWN, 3.3: UNKNOWN, 3.4: UNKNOWN ---------------------------------------- In #21701 a new argument `size:` was introduced, and its default value is `nil` (unknown). While I support the new argument, I'd argue that the default should be `Float::INFINITY`. **Reasoning:** By _design_, `Enumerator.produce` is infinite (there is no internal condition to stop iteration), and the simplest, most straightforward usages of the method would produce _definitely infinite_ iterators, which the user than can limit with `take`, or `take_while` or similar methods. To produce the enumerator that will stop by itself requires explicit raising of `StopIteration`, which I expect to be a (slightly) advanced technique, and those who use it might be more inclined to provide additional arguments to clarify the semantics. While `Enumerator#size` is hardly frequently used now (other than in `#to_set`, which started the discussion), it might be in the future, and I believe it is better to stick with more user-friendly defaults. Now: ```ruby # very trivial enumerator, but if you want it to have "proper" size, you need # to not forget to use an elaborate argument and type additional 21 characters Enumerator.produce(1, size: Float::INFINITY, &:succ) # already non-trivial enumerator, which is hardly frequently used, but the # current defaults correspond to its semantics: Enumerator.produce(Date.today) { raise StopIteration if it.tuesday? && it.day.odd? it + 1 } ``` With my proposal: ```ruby # trivial, most widespread case: Enumerator.produce(1, &:succ).size #=> Infinity # non-trivial case, with the enumerator designer clarifying their # intention that "we are sure it stops somewhere": Enumerator.produce(Date.today, size: nil) { raise StopIteration if it.tuesday? && it.day.odd? it + 1 } ``` -- https://bugs.ruby-lang.org/